You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

Canon EOS 5D Group / Discuss

Current Discussion

Noise @ ISO 800+
Latest: 12 minutes ago
Is the 85 1.8 on 5D worth it if you have 50 1.8 on 20D ?
Latest: 21 minutes ago
Look what I got just now! :D
Latest: 57 minutes ago
When 5D owners use a pocket camera, what do they use?
Latest: 4 hours ago
EF 100mm f/2.0 USM samples?
Latest: 10 hours ago
135mm L F2 lens: Should I get it?
Latest: 12 hours ago
and now for the next lens...
Latest: 18 hours ago
5D Gallery: Kids
Latest: 20 hours ago
135 f/2.0 L with the 5D - examples?
Latest: 21 hours ago
Are the 5D owners happy?
Latest: 22 hours ago
BP-511 x2 charger?
Latest: 2 days ago
Battery Contact Cleaning
Latest: 2 days ago
More...
spacer image

Slightly different banding on a 5D

view profile

Savara  Pro User  says:

Hello everyone,

Having my 5D for about a month or two now, and enjoying it really much. My main glass is a 24-70 2.8, but recently I took 70-200 f/4 and 50 1.4 for a shoot and stuck into heavy color noise banding, which is slightly different from the well-known AI-Servo banding problems. Crops inside. Any ideas?
Posted at 12:58AM, 15 May 2008 PDT ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:



70-200 f/4 @ ISO 1600
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:



50 1.4 @ ISO 3200
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Wooscary  Pro User  says:

I used to get that quite a lot, but don't seem to anymore. (I know nothing however), someone will come a long with an answer for you soon I imagine.
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:

I hope so. What did you change for the problem to go? Firmware, lens or something else?
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Shoeless Johnny  Pro User  says:

Did you increase your exposure in post on either of these shots? I know that I get real bad banding issues at high ISO when I try to increase the exposure more than 1/2 stop or if I try to selectively under-saturate a given channel (above ISO 400). I don't see banding otherwise.
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:

No, all settings were standard, exposure correction set to 0, but thanks for the hint
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Jake Lowe says:

I personally just wouldn't shoot at such high iso's
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Shoeless Johnny  Pro User  says:

The high ISO IQ is one of the features that makes the 5D such a sweet camera. What do you mean don't shoot at high ISO?
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Johnny Blood is a group administrator Johnny Blood  Pro User  says:

I think that particular lens has been cited as contributing to banding in some select cases. I personally don't know how widespread the problem is, but I'm sure you can find more online if you Yahoo! or Google it. You may also be experiencing some radio interference. You don't happen to have a TDMA/GSM cell phone, do you (i.e. T-Mobile, AT&T, Nextel)?

And yes, even a Ferarri can go 180 MPH, but that doesn't mean you should do it all of the time. There's a time and a place for everything. I don't know if I've ever shot at ISO 3200, and only black & white images at ISO 1600.
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:

It's actually two lenses - 70-200 f/4 and 50 1.4

It could be radio interference, but I always have a GSM phone, but it was not too close to the camera and transmitting anything at the particular moment of shooting - it has been a couple of hours between the shots.

I understand the stuff about ISOs, always trying to keep it as low as possible, and shooting at ISO3200 was just because I wanted to test of banding would become heavier - it did.
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Shoeless Johnny  Pro User  says:

Yeah, I have a AT&T phone and have not had a problem with interference or banding. When I have seen banding it does not look regular and repeating like what you show here. I think you should give Canon a call and get to the bottom of your problem.
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Mauricio11 says:

Did you read this? (at the bottom of the page)
www.dpreview.com/reviews/CanonEOS5D/page25.asp
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Savara  Pro User  says:

Mauricio11: Yes, I read this and no, this is a different banding, exactly as it is said at the top of the post, AND this was not AI-Servo. Any comments?
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to Canon EOS 5D Group discussion threads
Add to My Yahoo!