You aren't signed in     Sign In    Help

My MacBook Was Cracked By Itself / Discuss

Current Discussion

Why was our Macbook cracked? Share your ideas!
Latest: 2 days ago
how my problem was solved
Latest: 2 weeks ago
Describe Your Experience
Latest: 4 weeks ago
Is the keyboard replaced as well?
Latest: 4 weeks ago
Facebook Group
Latest: 2 months ago
Spoke to an Apple Rep Today who told me...
Latest: 4 months ago
The same exact spots?
Latest: 8 months ago
This issue is covered under the warranty!
Latest: 11 months ago
More...
spacer image

Why was our Macbook cracked? Share your ideas!

view profile

FHKE is a group administrator FHKE  Pro User  says:

Share your ideas at here!


My guess is the top case of the MacBook is not strong enough!
I notice one thing: most of the cracks are appear on the right hand side.
Since most people write with their right hand. When they use the TrackPad, they will place their hand on the right hand side of the TrackPad, and our hand exerts a little pressure to the MacBook top case from time to time. Therefore, the top case was pushed down. The edges of the top case are supported by the side of the bottom case, so it cracked!
Originally posted at 2:04PM, 11 February 2007 PDT ( permalink )
FHKE edited this topic 18 months ago.

Ben Schueddekopf [deleted] says:

Another thing may be, on the top of the screen is a plastic "bump" which when closed pushes down on the top of the case. Where my crack is seems to line up exactly where that bump is.
Posted 18 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

says:

I'm with Ben on that. Also keep in mind that the MacBook is held shut by magnets. And whenever I open it, I have the impression those magnets are rather strong - possibly too strong for the purpose.

See the Pimp My MacBook group for magnetic strength.

My dealer also said that the top case just rests on a very small rim of the MacBook's shell, so the force is really concentrated there. The fact that the case is hollow beneath the case (as can be seen on some of the photos here) probably makes cracks more likely as well.
Posted 16 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

FHKE is a group administrator FHKE  Pro User  says:

It is very likely that damages will appear on both side if they are cause by the magnets. If you check the photos in this group, most cracks only found on one side!
Posted 16 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

FHKE is a group administrator FHKE  Pro User  says:

Why was our MacBook cracked by itself?

The Macbook topcase is really thin..
Originally posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )
FHKE edited this topic 15 months ago.

view photostream

matg  Pro User  says:

Its not your hand its where the plastic ridge at the top of the screen at either side strike the casing when closing:


Originally posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )
matg edited this topic 15 months ago.

view photostream

_zand  Pro User  says:

I agree with most of you, it appears quite logical that the combination of repeated magnetic closing on a focal point and constant but oscillating hand pressure on a flexible surface when typing would break such a thin piece of plastic after a while.

It also seems that there aren't so many people having their macbooks break in such a way. It therefore seems quite clear that we have a flawed piece of equipment and that Apple should recall our machines or replace / repair at no expense.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

miraj a says:

Id agree, it wasnt your fault that it cracked. Its the plastic bump pushing too hard against the the plastic. Mine did crack on both sides, this happened to me at the same time as the shutdown problem so i took it back and got a replacement.

I think that apple were quite good about getting me a new one, on the phone they were totally useless, in store they were helpful.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

upaya_kausalya says:

how do you upload photos to the gallery - i have a big crack on my mac and so many things have gone wrong since i first bought it.
Posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

omolody  Pro User  says:

my girlfriend get the exact same crack problem with her macbook bought in september 2006 in germany -2 weeks ago..it s cover free of charge by the warranty. let see what will happen to mine which i bought in us in october 2006

it would be interested to know when you bought your laptops or better the production time...it seems that it could also be a miss handling of the molding process or plastic batch preparation.

>Might be interesting to see if the replacement piece are showing a different thickness than the original broken ones.
Originally posted 15 months ago. ( permalink )
omolody edited this topic 15 months ago.

view photostream

jamesmellor  Pro User  says:

Mine has cracked exactly the same way on both the left and the right side.. I think this is due to the magnetic latch and the raised area clamping down on it everytime it shuts - anyone had this replaced yet by Apple.. I need to sort mine.
Posted 13 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

Hãp  Pro User  says:

www.flickr.com/photos/huaopeng/966140494/
i show it on this picture
agree with jamesmellor
Posted 12 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

toin9898 says:

matq mine is exactly there.... im going to file down the bumps!!!!
Posted 8 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

ennailuj  Pro User  says:

It looked to me like it was the magnetic latch that caused it. BTW, we had to bring the MacBook (late 2006) to the Apple Store because the hard drive died (yes, it was backed up!) and they fixed the crack at the same time. I didn't even have to bring it up to the genius. She just saw it and put an order in to fix that as well.
Posted 8 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

lao_salo_maloo says:

mas querpa lotonstra kompanie...g9
Posted 2 months ago. ( permalink )

view photostream

annikaelvrum says:

Im very new to this, bought my Macbook in april 2008, and just today, July 24 i found crack on my computer. First on the right side then it appeared on the left side as well.. Im shocked since the computer is only 3 months old!! I been reading some of your experiences with this dilemma, and I was just wondering if anyone knows if the warranty is international?? I bought it in Barcelona, Spain but now going home to Sweden.. What I can remember the guy who sold it to me said its international warranty but just want to be sure..

And, will it be free of charge?? Think its pretty shitty when you buy a computer then it breaks, and on top of that, should have to pay for it..

Would be really happy if someone could help me since im clueless in computers, however, i am veeery careful with it. I always carry it around in my computer bag, never dropped it or anything like tht..

Thanks
Annika
Posted 2 days ago. ( permalink )

Would you like to comment?

Sign up for a free account, or sign in (if you're already a member).

RSS 2.0 feedSubscribe to a feed of stuff on this page...</!!> Feed – Subscribe to My MacBook Was Cracked By Itself discussion threads
Add to My Yahoo!